Tuesday, December 28, 2021

PT-2 Revelation" (Matt. 11;27)

 

SPIRITUAL DIARY FOR 12/28/2021 11:41 AM

 

My Worship Time                                                                                   Focus: PT-2 “Revelation”

 

Bible Reading & Meditation                                                         Reference:  Matt. 11:27

 

            Message of the verses: 27 "All things have been handed over to Me by My Father; and no one knows the Son except the Father; nor does anyone know the Father except the Son, and anyone to whom the Son wills to reveal Him. 

 

            I mentioned in our last SD that I kind of had the cart before the horse as we looked at this verse, but we will add some things in today’s SD as we look at this second truth from verse 27, which is explicit.  In our Lord’s deity He not only was intimate with His Father but had received “all things” including all authority, sovereignty, truth, and power that came from His Father.  MacArthur adds “At some time in preexistent eternity, the Father committed these ‘things’ to the Son (cf. John 5:21-24).”  “21 “For just as the Father raises the dead and gives them life, even so the Son also gives life to whom He wishes. 22 “For not even the Father judges anyone, but He has given all judgment to the Son, 23 so that all will honor the Son even as they honor the Father. He who does not honor the Son does not honor the Father who sent Him. 24  "Truly, truly, I say to you, he who hears My word, and believes Him who sent Me, has eternal life, and does not come into judgment, but has passed out of death into life.”

 

            We now conclude this second point as again I wish to quote from MacArthur’s commentary.  “It was because all authority had been given to Him ‘in heaven and on earth’ that Jesus had the right to send out His followers to ‘make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit’ (Matt 28:18-19).  The underlying purpose of Jesus’ miracles was to demonstrate His authority over illness, disease, demons, nature, life, death, and sin.  He had authority to forgive sins, to save from divine judgment, and to sovereignly control everything on earth and in heaven.  ‘All things’ in the universe and pertaining to the universe are under His divine sovereignty.  His power displayed during His ministry was a preview of the full display in the coming earthly millennium, when He will reign over the earth.”

 

            There is a third truth found in this verse and that is that “no one knows the Son except the Father.”  Man has no way in himself of discovering what God is like, because his finite mind cannot grasp God’s infinite nature.  Because the truth is that the Son is divine, as Jesus says, only the divine Father truly “knows” Him.  The obverse is equally true; “nor does anyone know the Father, except the Son, and anyone to whom the Son wills to reveal Him.”  The truth is that divine truth can only be divinely perceived and divinely imparted as seen in 1 Corinthians 2:9-16. 

 

            There are some who believe that philosophy and religion are the way to understand about God, or understand His truth, but that is not the case.  The only way that we can truly know God and know about God is through His Word and His Word teaches us about His Son who came to earth to die in our place, and also to show us about who the Father is.  It is God who must break into the darkness and emptiness of man’s human understanding and then show Himself before man can know Him.

 

            MacArthur concludes “When Jesus teaches here about God’s revelation of Himself  is at once simple and utterly profound.  It is to the person who sets aside all human knowledge and wisdom and becomes as an unlearned, helpless infant, that God chooses to ‘reveal’ Himself.  ‘No man has seen God at any time; the only begotten God, who is in the bosom of the Father, He has explained Him’ (John 1:18).  Only the person emptied of human wisdom can be filled with divine truth.

            Martin Luther said, ‘Here the bottom falls out of all merit, all powers and abilities or reason or the free will men dream of, and it all counts nothing before God.  Christ must do and must give everything.’”

 

            Spiritual meaning for my life today:  I am so very thankful that the Lord made Himself known to me, and it is my desire to serve Him and tell others what He has done for me in saving me.

 

My Steps of Faith for Today:  I am trusting the Lord that He will give comfort to the newest widow as our friend went into the presence of the Lord early this morning.  I will truly miss him.

 

12/28/2021 12:36 PM

 

Monday, December 27, 2021

PT-1 "Revelation" (Matt. 11:27)

 

SPIRITUAL DIARY FOR 12/27/2021 10:57 AM

 

My Worship Time                                                                                  Focus:  PT-1 “Revelation”

 

Bible Reading & Meditation                                                    Reference:  Matthew 11:27

 

            Message of the verses:  “27  "All things have been handed over to Me by My Father; and no one knows the Son except the Father; nor does anyone know the Father except the Son, and anyone to whom the Son wills to reveal Him.”

 

            We can look at these words of our Lord as a commentary on verse 25 which says “25 At that time Jesus said, "I praise You, Father, Lord of heaven and earth, that You have hidden these things from the wise and intelligent and have revealed them to infants.”  These words of Jesus in verse 27 expand on the truth that God has chosen to reveal His will to “babes or infants,” this as we have stated are the spiritually humble and helpless, rather than to those who are proud and self-reliant.  John MacArthur writes “A genuine invitation to salvation must consider God’s revelation, because no person, even the most determined or sincere, could know the way to Him unless the Lord had already made it known.  The way of salvation is disclosed only through the sovereign revelation of God.”  I can say that this statement is true, for as I look back at the time when I became a believer in Jesus Christ it was the furthest thing from my mind, although there were times before when the Lord was working on my heart.  As I moved along in my walk with the Lord and began to seek things from His Word I learned that what is found out in verse 27 made perfect sense to me.  The Lord saved me because He had chosen me before the foundation of the world, and so when the Holy Spirit of God gave me an effectual call to salvation, a call that I could not say no to I accepted that call and thus became a believer in Jesus Christ for the salvation that He offered when He died in my place on the cross almost 2000 years ago.  As stated this took a while in my walk with the Lord to understand this truth, but it is the only way that makes any sense to me, for before I became a believer I was spiritually dead, thus could not make any spiritual decisions.  I have told the story before about an undertaker who asked a dead man which tie he wanted, but of course got no answer.  He was physically dead and could not answer and all people are born spiritually dead and thus for them to become a believer they need the miracle of the effectual call to receive forgiveness from their sins.

 

            John MacArthur writes:  “The first important truth of this verse is not so much taught as taken for granted.  Jesus unequivocally equates Himself with God, call Him ‘My Father’ in a way that Jews would never do except when referring to His corporate fatherhood of Israel.  Here is one of Jesus’ clearest statements of His deity, disclosing the intimate and absolutely unique relationship of the ‘Father’ and the ‘Son.’  In essence they are one and are inseparable.”   

 

            I realize that I may have got the cart before the horse in talking about the effectual call, but there are times in my writing of these Spiritual Diaries that I have to talk about salvation as that is one of the most important reasons that I spend time in front of my computer each day writing things about the Word of God.

 

            We continue along the lines of the deity of Jesus Christ as everyone who becomes a believer in Jesus Christ must realize that He is God come in the flesh in order to show to Israel, and to the world who God really is.  Jesus told His disciples that “if You see Me you have seen the Father.”

 

            We conclude with this first truth from this verse as John MacArthur explains “That Jesus is Himself God is the heart of the gospel, because apart from His deity He could not save a single soul.  No heresy so corrupts the gospel and robs it of its power as the teaching that Jesus is not God.  Apart from His deity, there is no gospel and no salvation.”

 

            Spiritual meaning for my life today:  I praise the Lord that on the 26th of January, 1974 that my eyes were opened to the truth that Jesus Christ is God and that He came to save me, and all those who will accept this truth.

 

My Steps of Faith for Today:  For the last several weeks a dear friend of mine has been in the hospital, and a week ago we thought that he was getting better, but learned that was not the case so when you read about praying without ceasing that is what is what I have been doing for my friend and his family. 

 

12/27/2021 11:31 AM

 

           

Sunday, December 26, 2021

PT-4 "Humility and Dependence" (Matt. 11:25b-26)

 

SPIRITUAL DIARY FOR 12/26/2021 10:00 AM

 

My Worship Time                                                          Focus:  PT-4 “Humility and Dependence”

 

Bible Reading & Meditation                                            Reference:  Matthew 11:25b-26

 

            Message of the verses:  “that You have hidden these things from the wise and intelligent and have revealed them to infants. 26 "Yes, Father, for this way was well-pleasing in Your sight.”

 

            We want to talk about the “infants” as we begin this SD.  The infants or spiritual babes as is seen in other translations are those who acknowledge their utter helplessness in themselves, and to whom God has sovereignly chosen to reveal the truths of His kingdom.  Just a little reminder that we have been studying the book of Matthew for some 27 months now and the reminder is that Matthew’s gospel focuses in on the kingdom of God.  Back in the beatitudes we learned about “the poor in spirit” and it is those who humbly confess their dependency that God makes the way of salvation clear and understandable.  It is by the Holy Spirit that they recognize they are spiritually empty and bankrupt and so they abandon all dependence on their own resources to have a relationship with the Lord in order to be saved.  They realize that they can’t do this on their own.  They are the cringing spiritual beggars to whom Jesus refers in that first beatitude—they are absolutely destitute who are ashamed to lift up their head as they hold out their hands for help.

 

            The “infants” or spiritual babes are the exact opposite of the kind of person that the scribes and the Pharisees, and those that the rabbis taught about how to be pleasing to God.  “They are also the exact opposite of the imagined ideal Christian touted by many popular preachers and writers who glorify self-assertion and self worth,” writes John MacArthur.

 

            He goes on to write “The contrast between wise and intelligent and babes is not between the knowledgeable and the ignorant, the educated and the uneducated, the brilliant and the simpleminded.  It is a contrast between those who think they can save themselves by their own human wisdom, resources, and achievement and those who know they cannot.  It is a comparison between those who rely on themselves and those who rely on God.

            “People who are famous, highly educated, wealthy, powerful, or talented are often difficult to reach for Christ, simply because human accomplishments easily lead to pride and pride leads to self-sufficiency and self-satisfaction.”

 

            Now we move onto the last phrase in our verses where Jesus says "Yes, Father, for this way was well-pleasing in Your sight.”  What is it that God is well pleased with?  God is well pleased with the gospel of grace because it brings glory to Him, which is the supreme purpose in the universe.  “Q. What is the chief end of man? A. Man's chief end is to glorify God, and to enjoy him forever.” “Westminster Shorter Catechism”

 

            MacArthur quotes and unknown author:

 

 

“Still to the lowly soul

He doth Himself depart,

And for His dwelling and His throne

He chooses the humble heart.”

 

            Paul writes the following in 1 Cor. 1:26-27 “26  For consider your calling, brethren, that there were not many wise according to the flesh, not many mighty, not many noble; 27  but God has chosen the foolish things of the world to shame the wise, and God has chosen the weak things of the world to shame the things which are strong.”

 

            MacArthur concludes this section by writing:  “Jesus referred to Nicodemus as the ‘teacher of Israel,’ suggesting that he was perhaps the most highly respected rabbi in the land.  He was a student of the Old Testament and of the many traditional writings of Judaism.  Yet with all his religious training and knowledge, he could not grasp Jesus’ teaching that ‘unless one is born again, he cannot see the kingdom of God.’  Even after Jesus explained, Nicodemus did not understand, and Jesus said to him:  ‘Truly, truly, I say to you, we speak that which we know; and bear witness of that which we have seen; and you do not receive our witness.  If I told you earthly things and you do not believe, how shall you believe if I tell you heavenly things?’ (John 3:3-12).  Before he could comprehend or receive the gospel, Nicodemus had to go all the way back and start over as a spiritual babe, putting aside his human knowledge and achievements and coming to Christ with no merit of his own.”  The end of this story is that is what Nicodemus finally did.

 

12/26/2021 10:33 AM

 

 

Saturday, December 25, 2021

PT-2 "Is Christmas a Pagan Holiday"

 

Possible Source #1: The Early Church Understood the Jewish Priestly Calendar

This argument runs as follows:

1.      The course of priests on duty when the temple was destroyed can be estimated with a reasonable degree of accuracy (see Josef Heinrich Friedlieb’s Leben J. Christi des Erlösers. Münster, 1887, p. 312). This starting point may have been more commonly understood in Jewish families in the first and second centuries.

2.      There were 24 courses of priests (Neh. 12:12–21), of which Abijah is 8th. Working back from the course of Joarib serving on the 9th of Av (August 4th) in AD 70, you can determine when each course of priests served.

3.      Zacharias was from the course of Abijah (Luke 1:5), the eighth course of priests (Neh. 12:17), meaning that he would have served both during the 3rd week of Nisan (including the feasts of Passover and Unleavened Bread) and the 2nd week of Tishri (including the Day of Atonement) in 5 BC. 

4.      If the latter week is correct, then we can add 280 days (give or take a little) and arrive at the end of June for the birth of John the Baptist. Catholic tradition places the date of John’s birth on June 24.

5.      Now we just have to add 6 months to June 24 to find out when Jesus was born, because John was 6 months older than Jesus (Luke 1:24). This puts us at December 24–25.

There are some challenges with this schema:

1.      The entire argument, from our perspective, depends on the accuracy of Friedlieb’s claim regarding the priestly course of Joarib serving on the 9th of Av in AD 70.

2.      Because there were 24 courses of priests and 50 weeks in the year, the year we select for the birth of Christ could make a big difference in how this schema works.

3.      There is a 50/50 chance that Zacharias would have served either in Nisan or Tishri on the given year. Tishri backs up the chronology for the traditional dates, but it isn’t the only possibility. Proponents of this view may point to the “Infancy Gospel of James”, which has Zacharias entering the most holy place (see section 8), an act associated with the Day of Atonement. I don’t find the argument from the infancy gospel convincing.

Those challenges stated, if our understanding of the priestly rotation is correct and if the early church understood Zacharias as serving in the temple at or around the Day of Atonement, then it would be relatively easy to date Christmas on December 25th without any other influence.

Possible Source #2: The Early Church Counted Back from Easter

Somewhere along the line, the idea came about that Jesus was conceived on the day that he died. The origins of this thinking bear more investigation than I can trace out, but it’s a line of reasoning adopted by Augustine:

For He is believed to have been conceived on the 25th of March, upon which day also He suffered; so the womb of the Virgin, in which He was conceived, where no one of mortals was begotten, corresponds to the new grave in which He was buried, wherein was never man laid, neither before nor since. But He was born, according to tradition, upon December the 25th.

In other words, they worked back from what they were most certain (Jesus’s death on March 25th), assumed his conception was on the same day, and calculated his birth on December 25th. And there’s a long line of interpreters who argued for the March 25th crucifixion of Christ (a substantially earlier tradition than December 25th for Christmas). See, for example, Tertullian (mid second to early third century). 

While the argument for Jesus dying on the day of his conception seems incredibly forced to modern interpreters, it seems to have been a commonplace expectation of ancient interpreters. And it was reasonable enough for them to accordingly set the date of Christmas on December 25th. And the same argument seems to be in play in the Eastern Orthodox Church, where April 6th was argued as Christ’s death and conception and January 6th for his birth.

In summary, there is good reason to believe that the early church was not determining Easter based on Sol Invictus, but rather determining Christmas based on Easter.

Possible Source #3: The Early Church Understood the Historical Events Surrounding Christmas

Based on what we know of the eclipse around the time of Herod’s final illness, placing it in April of 4 BC, we can work backwards a few weeks for the disease to run its course, three to four weeks for the flight to Egypt, one week for Herod’s wait for the magi, and 6 weeks of purification before Jesus was presented. This gives a November or December date for Christmas (see Maier pages 124 and 127). 

The results here are a little more speculative, but the arguments are plausible because they rely on a known historical event as recorded by Josephus. They also don’t arrive exactly at the specific date of December 25th, but a little flexibility in the weeks could make it work.

Conclusion

Without making an appeal to history (i.e., that the early church had better access to historical records and sources), we can chart three possible routes for the early church to arrive at the December 25th date of Christmas via known and extant sources. We can also make a compelling case that pagan alternatives would have been rejected by Christians at this time and that the Christian mentions of the December 25th date predate the mentions of a pagan celebration. So I feel confident in arguing that December 25th was not a pagan holiday converted into a Christian one, but a date arrived at by one of many possible lines of evidence.

Additional Reading

The following sites provide some excellent jumping-off points and additional arguments related to the issue of the “pagan Christmas” festival:

·         https://www.biblicalarchaeology.org/daily/biblical-topics/new-testament/how-december-25-became-christmas/

·         https://insidethevatican.com/news/lead-story/the-25th-of-december-pagan-feast-or-patristic-tradition/

·         https://www.crosswalk.com/special-coverage/christmas-and-advent/was-jesus-really-born-on-dec-25.html 

·         https://taylormarshall.com/2012/12/yes-christ-was-really-born-on-december.html 

·         http://penelope.uchicago.edu/~grout/encyclopaedia_Romana/calendar/invictus.html 

·         http://inchristus.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/maier-date-of-the-nativity.pdf 

 

Friday, December 24, 2021

PT-1 "Is Christmas a Pagan Holiday"

 

CHRISTMAS

IS DECEMBER 25TH A PAGAN HOLIDAY?

DECEMBER 2, 2019 PHILIPMT LEAVE A COMMENT

A quick Google search will find millions of articles connecting the date of Christmas to a pagan Roman festival. They come from websites on history, news, and theology, to name a few. Their claim isn’t a new one, by any stretch. One of the first assertions of this connection between a festival of the sun and Christmas came from the Syriac Orthodox Bishop Jacob Bar-Salibi, writing from Mesopotamia in the 12th century (see Bibliotecha orientalis Clementino-Vaticanae 2:164). But does that claim stand up to historical scrutiny?

Clarifying the Question

At the outset, I want to ensure that we frame the question well. The question that I’m going to answer is not, “Was December 25th the exact day of Jesus’ birth?” That’s a muddy question to attempt to answer for a number of reasons. It raises issues of whether shepherds would be in the field on a December night and the precision of numerous points of evidence we’ll address in a bit. 

Another question that is beyond the scope of this article is whether modern Christmas traditions like the Christmas tree, Yule log, mistletoe, etc. are pagan adaptations. I’m also not going to wade into whether the adaptation or overhauling of pagan holidays or practices pose a moral problem for Christians. Instead, I will answer the question, “Did the early church adopt a pagan holiday or did they have other reasons for adopting the December 25th date for Christmas?”

I would affirm that the church had solid non-pagan reasons for adopting the December 25th date for Christmas. Some of these reasons have more validity to me than others, but I find the evidence for non-pagan origins of the December 25th date of Christmas compelling. Unlike other posts along these lines, I have tried, where possible, to link to original source material so readers who wish to check my research can do so.

The Early Christian Resistance to Paganism

Early Christians detested the thought of amalgamating their faith with Roman paganism or any other sort of non-Christian faith. Owing to its Jewish origin and the writings of the New Testament, early Christians held a strong position against syncretistic efforts, choosing rather to suffer persecution than to add Christ to the Roman pantheon or adapt Christian teaching or practice to that of the pagan culture. Some early examples of this trend are worth noting.

In the Epistle to Diognetus, a writer who merely designates himself as a “disciple” writes one of the early examples of Christian apologetics (probably mid- to late-second century). In his second chapter, the writer explains why Christians hold pagan practices in “contempt.” Justin Martyr is another early example of Christian apologists (early- to late-second century). Time-and-again, Justin excoriates pagan practices, leaving no room for any sort of amalgamation with pagan practices (see particularly his “First Apology” chapters 9 and 24). A third early exemplar of this anti-pagan tradition in the early church is Irenaeus (mid second to early third century). In his second book of “Against Heresies,” one of his arguments that he deploys to attack the Gnostic teachings of Valentinus is that they have been derived from pagan mythology. Irenaeus expects his readers to detest any sort of substitution of Christian nomenclature, theology, or practice with that of paganism.

But while the early Christians resisted syncretistic practices, the cults of the day exercised little discretion in borrowing from Christian traditions. In fact, one of the early offenders in this regard was the cult of Mithras. Mithras was a cult that gained popularity in the Roman empire during the first century alongside Christianity. Details of the cult remain sparse, leading to many scholarly conjectures about its origins and practices. While scholars debate whether the early Christian apologists had an accurate understanding of Mithraism, we do have two indications of a syncretistic effort within the Mithras cult. For example, during the second century, Justin Martyr accuses Mithraism of borrowing the Christian elements of the Eucharist. And later Tertullian (late second to early third century) suggests that Mithraism and other pagan traditions, as servants of Satan, are attempting to borrow Christian practices as their own. 

Academics in the field of history of religions frequently argue that because Mithraism pre-dated Christianity (Mithras was the Persian sun god, with extant references before the time of Christ), Christians must have adopted and adapted elements of the cult in their own worship and theology. But all of the scholarly work on Mithraism admits several important elements:

1.      Mithraism was not static, but evolved rapidly as it encountered Roman culture and religions. Even the amalgamation with Sol Invictus was part of this evolution. To posit that Mithraism, favored by the emperors of the era, incorporated Christian elements to draw Roman citizens away from Christianity makes more sense than the persecuted church adapting Christianity to Mithraism (or the early generation of Jewish disciples adapting Judaism to Mithraism).

2.      Mithraism lacks robust extant primary sources for study. We do have some extant references and know that some writers in the ancient world provided far more detail on the cult. Because many of the details are lacking, academics are left to interpret history, to fill in the blanks.

3.      Because of the evolving nature and because we don’t have many sources to research, later summaries of the practices and beliefs surrounding Mithras and Sol Invictus have been interpolated into the historic practices of the cult. The best way to unravel the connection is to examine the trail of historical evidence surrounding specific elements where overlap is alleged to find their source. This article attempts to do this with the most notable of alleged Mithras/Christianity overlaps.

In short, early in Christian tradition we find deep-seated resistance to any sort of syncretistic amalgamations of Christian worship and practice (particularly of Mithraism). Instead, we find that Roman paganism (particularly Mithraism) was well positioned to absorb unique Christian practices for their own.

Which Came First?

We’ve thus far established that it seems plausible that the Mithras cult borrowed from Christianity rather than the other way around. So what does this have to do with the date of Christmas? The legend of “pagan Christmas” suggests that Christians borrowed the December 25th date from Natalis Invicti, the birth of Sol Invictus–a sister cult to that of Mithras. In order for this legend to be true, we need evidence that supports (a) prior pagan celebrations on December 25 and (b) later Christian celebrations on December 25. Instead, here’s what we find when we examine the source material:

1.      A pagan holiday on December 25th is is poorly attested.

·         Many sources (see this one in the Washington Post, for a more popular example) point to the Roman Emperor Aurelian as “the Father of Christmas”, alleging that he launched the holiday of Natalis Invicti in AD 274. This late third century date for Natalis Invicti, however, is unsubstantiated. We know that Aurelian returned to Rome in triumph and dedicated a temple to the Sun (for extensive research on this temple and related imagery, see Roger Pearse’s articles). Beyond those facts, we find nothing about December 25th in the three key primary sources on Aurelian (Historia Augusta, “The Deified Aurelian”, XXV.6;  Sextus Aurelius Victor, Epitome de Caesaribus XXXV; Eutropius, Abridgement of Roman History IX.13–15). As best I can tell by chasing the primary sources, historians who posit the AD 274 origin of the December 25th celebration are reading more recent practices back into what may have happened in 274.

·         So what is that more recent source that is read back into Aurelian’s temple dedication? The first indication of the Natalis Invicti celebration on December 25th comes from a mid 4th century calendar that features key dates celebrated by the Roman government in the year 354. There it notes “N·INVICTI·CM·XXX.” Even here, we should note that the description here is not incredibly specific, lacking the word “SOL”, which appears elsewhere in the calendar. “CM·XXX” indicates an event that involved 30 races in the Roman circus. It should also be noted that later in the same document, when listing Christian observances, the same date is listed as the “birth of Christ in Bethlehem of Judea.” In summary, the “Chronography of 354” is by no means a straightforward document. While the dates included in the chronography surely began at an earlier time, this is the first possible historical instance of a pagan December 25th celebration; however, this is not the first historical instance of December 25th being noted as the birthday of Jesus.

2.      A Christian tradition supporting December 25th as the birthdate of Jesus Christ has much earlier attestation in ancient literature. 

·         Hippolytus (late-second to early-third century) states that “the first advent of our Lord in the flesh, when he was born in Bethlehem, was December 25th [lit. eight days before the Kalends of January], Wednesday” (see Commentary on Daniel, page 140 and an additional discussion on the text tradition). 

·         Another example here is an early tradition that Telesphorus (early to late second century) set the date for “the season of nativity”. The textual evidence here is challenging, but most of the other details in the “Book of Popes” (this early part attributed to Jerome, late fourth to mid fifth century) aligns well with the records of Irenaeus and Eusebius. 

3.      Questionable sources are often cited as evidence for a “pagan Christmas” background.

·         One such example is the quotation alleged to be from Augustine: “We hold this day holy, not like the pagans because of the birth of the sun, but because of him who made it.” It would be possible to read this statement either as an admission that December 25th was initially adopted to subvert earlier pagan tradition or as a defense of Christian tradition’s non-pagan foundations. But even here, I can’t find any primary source for this quotation.

·         Another category in question is the iconography surrounding Sol Invictus. While some sources on the topic draw on coinage or inscriptions for primary information on Sol Invictus and how it may integrate with Christianity, many of the alleged icons are questionable, at best. 

·         A variety of claims about Christian/Mithraic parallels that work well on memes or in rapid-fire YouTube comments don’t stand up to careful analysis. This list of four alleged parallels with some helpful documentation will help kickstart some helpful research.

·         I’ve seen a number of sources pointing to more ancient Juvenalia or Saturnalia celebrations as the source for the December 25th date of Christmas; however, the dates for these festivals occurred earlier in December.

In summary: While Christians in the fifth century and beyond showed gradually greater degrees of syncretism, careful historians will be hard-pressed to make the case that even in the second and early third centuries–before the legalization of Christianity–that Christians were already adopting and adapting the pagan religions of Rome. Further, the earliest sources that specifically refer to the Christian celebration of Christ’s birth and not to any pagan festival.

So if December 25th wasn’t a pagan holiday, where else could it have come from? Let’s look at three intriguing possibilities.